Posted Jun 04, 2021, Updated May 27, 2024 In my opinion no ice cream shop or store-bought ice cream variety even comes close to being as delicious as homemade ice cream – especially when it comes to this Oreo ice cream recipe. When you make your own, like this chocolate ice cream or chocolate peanut butter ice cream, you control the quality of ingredients, amount of add ins, etc. Which is why I created this recipe for the best cookies and cream ice cream ever. In this recipe, creamy Oreo ice cream is loaded with crushed and chopped cookies for a big Oreo flavor in every bite! No searching through a sea of plain vanilla ice cream to disappointedly find that there are only a few bits of Oreos – this recipe is jam-packed with the good stuff (cookies galore).
Cookies and Cream Ice Cream: Ingredients & Substitutions
Here are a few notes about the ingredients and possible substitutions in this Oreo ice cream recipe.
Half and half/heavy cream. This recipe calls for 3 cups of liquid dairy. You can change the ratios of half and half : cream if desired, as long as the total amount equals 3 cups. You could also substitute some of the liquid with whole milk. Granulated sugar. Organic cane sugar works well in place of white granulated sugar. Fine sea salt. if using iodized salt, reduce the amount by half. Egg yolks. There is no substitution for egg yolks in this Oreo ice cream recipe. Pure vanilla extract. I don’t recommend using imitation vanilla. However vanilla bean paste is a good substitute. Oreos cookies: Any sandwich cookie (or really any crunchy cookie of your choice) works well in this recipe. I suggest any flavor of Oreos (we love double stuff ), Trader Joe’s Jo Jo’s, or you can even find a gluten-free variety to make this recipe gluten-free. Just be sure to realize that you process some of the cookies and coarsely chop the rest.
How to Make Oreo Ice Cream
This Oreo ice cream recipe has a few steps, but they are simple and easy to execute! We’ll walk through the process step-by-step, and don’t forget to watch the video. This cookies and cream ice cream recipe begins by making the ice cream base – because it needs to be chilled until cold. To begin, warm the half and half, salt and sugar over medium heat. In a separate bowl, beat the egg yolks and add ½ cup of the warm mixture to the egg yolks, then whisk to combine. Next, add the egg mixture to the half and half on the stovetop. Cook over medium-low heat stirring constantly until the mixture thickens slightly – just barely coating the back of a spatula – or reaches 170 degrees F. Place the heavy cream into a bowl with a fine mesh strainer on top of the bowl, then strain the custard into the heavy cream and discard what is left on the strainer. Add vanilla extract and stir to combine.
Chill
Transfer the ice cream mixture to an airtight container and chill completely in the fridge (preferably overnight).
Churn
Once chilled, turn an ice cream make on and pour mixture into it while it’s turning. Churn until it begins to thicken and add the finely crushed Oreos. Continue churning until thick and frozen. Once frozen, transfer the Oreo ice cream to a freezer-friendly container with a lid and stir in coarsely chopped cookies. Then freeze until hardened.
Serve
Enjoy this cookies n cream ice cream with a dollop of homemade whipped cream and chocolate sauce for an extra special treat! We love using it as one of the layers in this homemade ice cream cake!
Store
This Oreo ice cream can be stored in the freezer for up to 3 months.
Ice Cream Making Tools
Ice cream maker: I have this Cuisinart Ice Cream maker. I bought it at a garage sale and got a great deal on it! If I was going to purchase a new one, I would get this nicer version Cuisinart Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker because it’s bigger and newer, and relatively similar in price. Storage container: I store our homemade ice cream in a glass tupperware with a lid. There are also great containers that are made for storing ice cream, like these 1-quart storage tubs and this jumbo 2.5 quart container (for larger batches). Ice cream scoop: I have a little collection of ice cream scoops! I like using a large cookie scoop because it makes pretty, round servings of ice cream due to the shape and release feature. The shape of this scoop makes it easy to serve ice cream!
If you make and love our recipes, it would mean so much to me if you would leave a comment and rating! And don’t forget to follow along with us on Instagram, Pinterest, Facebook, and Youtube – be sure to tag @joyfoodsunshine and use the hashtag #joyfoodsunshine so we can see your creations!
