Posted Jul 01, 2018, Updated Sep 28, 2021 I’m in love! I’m in LOVE! And I don’t care who knows it! In love with this Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream recipe. I’m totally serious too. What’s not to love?! An ice cream recipe that is dairy-free, irresistibly chocolatey, and loaded with chunks of peanut butter cookie dough is basically what all my dreams are made of! Something I absolutely cannot understand about ice cream shops is that all the ice cream varieties with the best mix-ins always have a vanilla base. And since I believe that dessert isn’t worth eating unless it’s loaded with chocolate, you won’t find me ordering said varieties. So once again, to create a truly dreamy ice cream recipe, I resort to making my own. And ladies and gents this recipe does not disappoint.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream: Ingredients & Substitutions
Let’s chat about the ingredients used in this cookie dough ice cream recipe, as well as possible substitutions!
Old-fashioned oats. Use ready-made oat flour for the old-fashioned oats in this recipe. Old-fashioned oats yield a 1:1 ratio of oats:oat flour. what I mean is that 1/2 cup oats yields 1/2 cup oat flour! So please, if substituting, be sure to use a full 1/2 cup oat flour! All-purpose or all-purpose gluten-free flour should work in this recipe as well!Peanut butter. If desired, sub any nut or seed butter. Coconut oil. Butter or ghee are great substitutions for coconut oil.Coconut sugar. Any granulated sugar works well in this recipe. Just be sure to choose a variety that complies with your dietary needs.Honey/Maple Syrup. I prefer honey, but maple syrup also tastes amazing and can be used to create a vegan option.Mini chocolate chips. I love the mini chocolate chips in the cookie dough in this recipe, however they can easily be omitted if you prefer to leave them out, without sacrificing taste.Coconut Cream. I adore making dairy-free ice cream with coconut cream (the whole can, liquid and solid portions). I think it yields the creamiest result possible. However, full-fat coconut milk can also be used with delicious results.
How to make peanut butter cookie dough ice cream
Let’s walk through how to make this recipe step-by-step so all of your ice cream dreams can come true! Don’t forget to watch the video.
Make the Peanut Butter Cookie Dough
Note: You will notice that the peanut butter cookie dough is a little bit sticky and soft. That is exactly how we want it to be so it is easy to eat when it is frozen!
Make the Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream
While the peanut butter cookie dough is freezing, it’s time to make the chocolate peanut butter ice cream base! Use a Vitamix. To make the ice cream base, add all of the ingredients into the container of your Vitamix and blend until smooth. Turn on the ice cream maker! Important tip: When using an ice cream maker it is crucial that you turn the machine on before pouring the mixture into it! Pouring ice cream into an already moving container ensures that it will not freeze to the bottom or sides, which could hinder the churning process by preventing the machine from rotating. Churn! Next pour the mixture into an ice cream maker and let it churn! It’s very important that (unlike many other recipes) you do not chill the chocolate peanut butter ice cream mixture made in the Vitamix before pouring it into the ice cream maker! It must go directly from the Vitamix into the ice cream maker. The container of the ice cream maker DOES need to be frozen, however! How to know it’s finished. When your Dairy-Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream forms a ball and no longer has a liquid consistency, it is done! At this point it could become so thick that the ice cream maker stops rotating, which is another indicator that it’s ready!
Put it together
Once the ice cream has finished churning and the peanut butter cookie dough is hardened, it’s time to put everything together to make this Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Ice Cream. Transfer the chocolate peanut butter ice cream to a freezer-friendly container. I use a glass container similar to this one to store my ice cream and I love it! Cut and add the Peanut Butter Cookie Dough. Remove the cookie dough from the freezer and chop it into small pieces with a sharp knife. Add it to the ice cream in the freezer-friendly container and stir until it’s evenly distributed.
Freeze/Store
Let the peanut butter cookie dough ice cream freeze for at least 1 hour before eating! It can be stored in the freezer for up to 2 months.
Enjoy!
I recommend removing the peanut butter cookie dough ice cream from the freezer about 5 minutes before you would like to eat it so that it is easier to scoop! If you make and love our recipes, it would mean so much to me if you would leave a comment and rating! And don’t forget to follow along with us on Instagram, Pinterest, Facebook, and Youtube – be sure to tag @joyfoodsunshine and use the hashtag #joyfoodsunshine so we can see your creations! The links in this post are affiliate links, thank you for supporting JoyFoodSunshine.
